What is it with turning regular everyday activities into contests? The simple joy of eating a hot dog is now a sanctioned event governed by the International Federation of Competitive Eating (IFOCE). Ironing is now an extreme sport as is growing a beard. Don’t get me wrong…as both a competitive person and a male (age 18 to 35) I can appreciate a ridiculous challenge. And while I am skeptical about reading for sport, I feel that if you will do so there needs to be rules.
Foolhardy readers beware
This morning, I came across the following blog post on Flavorwire.com; 10 Novels That We Dare You to Finish. The post encourages “foolhardy readers” to list and comment on which titles they finished quickly. In a related blog post I found links to free ebook copies of five massive novels. GallyCat editor Jason Boog enjoys reading electronic versions of long novels. The mammoth books are easier to interact with when they appear on a single, flat screen.
Boog does raise an interesting point. Downloading a free version of something like War and Peace is more convenient than borrowing it from the local library. But if one is being challenged (or in the case of Flavorwire … “dared”) to read these titles, then I would argue that downloading the “e” version is cheating.
Challenging Yourself (and others)
If you will try reading for sport, I feel you should only read the print-versions. It wouldn’t be the same experience otherwise. The most cumbersome book I own is Carl Jung’s The Red Book (Liber Novus). The book is a whopping 15 by 12 inches and almost 10 pounds. When I read it, my wife thinks I look like a Benedictine Monk studying some ancient text. The content of Jung’s book is fascinating. And I can’t imagine one having the same experience with an ebook version. I don’t even know if an electronic version exists to be honest. What little remains of the book’s original simulacrum is diminished when converted and displayed in electronic form.
For most readers, the simple joy of reading is motivation enough to tackle War and Peace or The Red Book. But if you’re going to challenge people who would not normally read “long, long books,” then I would force these folks to stick to print books. You should have to lug them around with you in all their unwieldy glory. In doing so, it will make for a richer experience. At the very least, when the challenge is over, you’ll still have a physical version of the book. Like a trophy on a bookshelf from some sporting challenge, it will stand as proof of your prior conquest.
What do you think? Agree? Disagree?